Welcome to this week's Recommendation Engine from Podcast Rex, rounding up the week in podcast reviews. Get this in an email each week by signing up to be a supporter of Podcast Rex from £3.99.
Platforms
Apple Podcasts: New Shows
The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger)
Olivia’s House (Lemonada/Listen)
True Crime Catch Up (Audio Always)
Spotify: New & 🔥
Game’s Gone (BBC Radio 5 Live)
Stay on Track (The Athletic/The Race)
Amazon Music: Best Podcasts of the Week
The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger)
True Crime Catch Up (Audio Always)
Game’s Gone (BBC Radio 5 Live)
Pocket Casts: Featured
A Question of Science (The Francis Crick Institute/BBC Studios)
Reviews
Miranda Sawyer in the Observer
- The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger) - "You don’t really care about the hopping about. There is just so much fun in this charming podcast.”
- Gangster Presents… Sex Drugs & Cell Block Parties (BBC Sounds) - “Meet Amy, who was working as a therapist in HMP Lindholme in north Yorkshire when she found herself falling for one of the inmates, Joe, a “cheeky chappy” from Bradford, who ends up being a little trickier than that sounds. We meet Joe’s parents, who are sweet, if resigned. ‘I said to him many times, you’re not any good at being a criminal so why don’t you pack it in?’ says his dad.”
Gerard O’Donovan in the Daily Telegraph
- The Bomb (BBC World Service) - “Moves us forward into the Cold War struggle for nuclear supremacy and the terrifying story of how the Cuban Missile Crisis brought the world to the brink of nuclear annihilation in 1962.”
- The History Podcast: The Arrest (BBC Radio 4) - “Gripping.”
- Defiant (Stak) - “A six-part podcast relating how boxing helped Iraq War veteran Eric Morante overcome amputation, PTSD and addiction.”
- That’s Not How It Went Down (ind.) - “A special episode finds the ‘based on a true story’ spotlight turn on possibly the greatest dance film ever made, Saturday Night Fever.”
- Life Changing (BBC Radio 4) - “Another absorbing edition.”
- Aftershock: The War on Terror (London Review of Books) - “Engrossing.”
In The List
- The Comedy Bureau (ind.) - “An academically inclined but accessible podcast in which she and her former university tutor, Dr Oliver Double, discuss the history and theories behind comedy. At a time when the artform is keeping theatres open but struggling for government recognition and financial support, it’s a fond exploration that demands laughter be taken seriously. Equally, it respects comedy’s mystery and magic, never dissecting the metaphorical frog so strenuously that it dies.” ★★★★☆
Lucy White in the Irish Independent
- The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger) - “An entertaining and cerebral double act.”
- The Green Alliance Podcast (ind.) - “The Green Alliance may be a UK think-tank but its areas of study are universal; likewise conversations around how AI can help and hinder the climate crisis, carbon capture, disposable vapes, rewilding and media messaging.”
- Media Storm (ind.) - “An investigative current affairs series that looks beyond the clickbait.”
Listings
The New Yorker revealed their best podcasts of 2025, including
- Fela Kuti: Fear No Man (Audible/Higher Ground)
- Final Thoughts: Jerry Springer (Audible)
- Spotlight: Snitch City (The Boston Globe)
- A Tiny Plot (KQED)
- Camp Swamp Road (Spotify/Wall Street Journal)
- The History Podcast (BBC Radio 4)
- Articles of Interest: Gear (Radiotopia)
- Heavyweight (Pushkin)
- Uncover: Sea of Lies (CBC)
- The Audio Flux Podcast (ind.)
- Signal Hill (ind.)
The Week US released their most memorable podcasts from Autumn
- Heavyweight (Pushkin)
- The Adam Friedland Show (ind.)
- In the Dark: Blood Relatives (The New Yorker)
- Camp Swamp Road (Spotify/Wall Street Journal)
- Inklings Book Club (Independent)
Clair Woodward in the Sunday Times
- The Third Act (ind.)
- Katherine Ryan’s Christmas Intervention (Audible)
- The Bomb (BBC World Service)
- Charles Dickens’ Ghost Stories with David Suchet (Noiser)
- The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger)
The Guardian’s Best Podcasts of the Week
- Bottoms Up (Listen)
- The Girlfriends: Untouchable (Novel)
- Music Makes Us (Talkhouse/Radiotopia)
- Charles Dickens’ Ghost Stories with David Suchet (Noiser)
- The Bomb (BBC World Service)
The Guardian Weekly magazine’s Podcast of the Week
In the Saturday Guardian magazine
In the Radio Times
- David Greene Is Obsessed (Campside) - Pick of the Week
- Ready to Talk (BBC Sounds)
- The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger)
- Adrift (Apple TV)
- Bad Cousins (The Diasporist/Kollo Media)
- Matt Chorley’s Urgent Questions (BBC Radio 5 Live)
- Business History (iHeart/Pushkin)
- Homing (ind.)
- Legends of News (ind.)
In i Weekend
- The Rest Is Science (Goalhanger)
- Gangster Presents… Sex Drugs & Cell Block Parties (BBC Sounds)
- Help Me I’m Single (PodcastOne)
- The Pitcairn Trials (Audio Always/Wondery)
Heat’s Top of the Pods






